Castle Hill Supper Club

Great classic supper club. They were pretty busy when we got there, with a wedding reception and a large party. But the service was great. The wife and I both had the prime rib and baked potato. It had great flavor and cooked perfectly. We both went with soup vs salads (it's the way of the north👍) hers being the clam chowder, mine the chicken noodle, We both agreed the soups were wonderful. Oh yeah, let's not forget the Old Fashioneds (brandy of course) the were quite tasty as well. We had the Brandy Alexander desserts for dessert, most wonderful. It was a great experience and we agreed it was a good value as well. Highly recommend!!

We went for the All-You-Can-Eat Friday night Seafood Buffet. It was okay. Decent variety of baked, fried, and boiled seafood options (fish [haddock & catfish], clams, and shrimp), but not anything special like Wisconsin lakes fish like walleye, perch, bluegill, or anything like that. Usual sides like fries, mashed potatoes, and pasta salads. Salad and dessert bars were good. Service was okay but not very personable or friendly. Efficient (removing used dishes, etc.). Fairly reasonable prices. Felt a bit like a cafeteria, I guess, though. No atmosphere in the big seating hall. It got crowded pretty quickly after opening but there is a huge amount of seating, so we didn't see anybody having to wait too long to get a table. The cook was always checking the status of the buffet so there was adequate food coming out. Not sure we'll be back though because the buffet was like a lot of other chain buffet places and didn't offer anything unique and the service wasn't especially friendly. Noted that the place is for sale. That may have something to do with those issues. Maybe new owners/management can make some needed changes.